The most recent oral arguments for the Joel Tenenbaum case have been posted online.

Hearing the file sharing debates in this form, as well as, the two sides going back and forth is quite interesting. The judge challenges the Department of Justice lawyer on many key points and they notably dance around some of them. The audio is long, but it's worth tuning into to see the court's version of the file sharing debates. Listen below:

Oral Arguments In The Joel Tenenbaum Appeal by user1734503